The One Click Group

The One Click Group
Health Advocacy

RSS Feed Follow OneClickGroup on Twitter

Dr Iain Stephenson
Found Guilty of Vaccine
Research Fraud
The One Click Group

Mobilising ME/CFS Charities
To Smash Flawed
PACE Trial Results
Lara, Health Advocate

UK Public Health
In Dire Straits
Dr Dick van Steenis MBBS

Lies Damned Lies
Swine Flu
Statistics Exposed
By Lara

Vaccination Graphs
The Awful Stats In Action
Raymond Obomsawin Ph.D

Issues In Immunization
Theory And Practice
Raymond Obomsawin Ph.D

March 2010

One Click
Of Information
UK Police Harassment
In The Internet Era

Barbara Loe Fisher
NVIC Conference
Style, Gonads
Brass Ovaries
By Jane Bryant

New Journalism
Status Quo
By Jane Bryant
NVIC Conference

How The
Judicial Review
NICE Guidelines
Was Lost
Jane Bryant
The One Click Group

Vaccines Propaganda
David Salisbury
Public Relations

David Southall
"A Very
Dangerous Doctor"
Panorama swims
with sharks
Lisa Blakemore Brown

Dr David Salisbury
Never Mind Me,
I'm Basil Fawlty!

David Salisbury
Vaccine Litigation

The Politics
And Commerce
Of Autism
By Lisa Blakemore Brown

Vaccine/Autism Case
Mitochondrial Disfunction
ME/CFS Patients

The Consensus Report
Family Law Reform

Canadian Definition of ME-CFS

The Weird World of Wikipedia
By Martin J. Walker

Click here to email us with any thoughts or opinions you wish to share about the website.


News Archives 3281-3300
Number Title Post Date
3281 Doctors Call For Halt To NHS Patients' Database 10/03/2010 15:15:37
3282 UK Data Liberty - Hang The Politicians 10/03/2010 15:19:35
3283 DSHEA Repeal Legislation Delayed, Not Dead 12/03/2010 09:53:15
3284 Nanotoxicity In Regulatory Vacuum 12/03/2010 10:03:45
3285 Central Figure in CDC Vaccine Cover-Up Absconds With $2M 12/03/2010 10:08:49
3286 Wyeth/Pfizer Vaccine Chief Justice Recuses Over Shareholdings 12/03/2010 10:17:21
3287 New Report Raises Gardasil Vaccine Concerns 12/03/2010 10:22:04
3288 West Coast School Rejects HPV Vaccine 12/03/2010 10:32:07
3289 New Study Shows Flu Vaccines Are Futile Rubbish 12/03/2010 10:36:35
3290 Science Triumphs For Gulf War Veterans In Their Battle With The VA 12/03/2010 10:40:15
3291 UK Industry And Electorate Alike Condemn Mandelson's Digital Economy Bill 12/03/2010 10:43:37
3292 French Bread Spiked With LSD In CIA Experiment 12/03/2010 11:05:31
3293 MPs Criticise Biased Science & Technology Committee Report On Homeopathy 13/03/2010 16:19:52
3294 Corrupt Scientist Who Lied About Vaccines And Autism Vanishes With Millions 13/03/2010 16:23:29
3295 Don't Let The Labour Government Disconnect The Internet 13/03/2010 16:28:41
3296 Iceland Sets New Path Toward Press Freedom 13/03/2010 16:32:00
3297 Ex-Pfizer Worker Cites Genetically Engineered Virus In Lawsuit 15/03/2010 07:09:24
3298 Four Babies Dead And 17 Ill After Vaccine Shots 15/03/2010 08:40:57
3299 Report Links Vaccines To Gulf War Syndrome 15/03/2010 08:42:33
3300 New Report - Vitamin D Better Than Vaccines At Preventing Flu 15/03/2010 08:45:31

[Previous] [Next]

New Study Shows Flu Vaccines Are Futile Rubbish
Share |

March 11, 2010
Flu shots futile: study
By Tom Blackwell

Nursing Home Test: 'Didn't find' proof immunization stops virus

Study co-author Dr. Tom Jefferson says he
"can't see any reason" for vaccinating anyone
against flu -- arguing the shots did nothing to
save lives -- and that most influenza-vaccine
studies are "rubbish."

A new Canadian-led study has added to a simmering scientific dispute over flu-shot campaigns, concluding that immunizing nursing-home workers does nothing to cut the number of confirmed influenza cases among the homes' elderly residents.

Coming at the end of the largest flu-vaccination campaign in Canadian history, the review of previous studies calls for stepped-up research into alternative, lower-tech ways to combat the virus, such as improved hand washing.

"What troubled us is that [shots] had no effect on laboratory-confirmed influenza," said Dr. Roger Thomas of the University of Calgary, lead author of the paper published by the respected Cochrane Library.

"What we were looking for is proof that influenza ... is decreased. Didn't find it. We looked for proof that pneumonia is reduced. Didn't find it. We looked for proof deaths from pneumonia are reduced. Didn't find it."

A prominent flu expert, however, calls the authors' conclusions misleading, noting that vaccinating workers does, in fact, lessen the amount of influenza-like sickness and the number of deaths from all causes among those nursing-home denizens. That is all that really matters, said Dr. Allison McGeer, infectious disease specialist at Toronto's Mount Sinai Hospital.

"There is [very little] that you or I can do that is more effective at preventing deaths than vaccinating health-care workers in long-term care facilities," she said. "That's the bottom line .... There is no question."

The studies could not accurately gauge the effect of vaccination on actual laboratory-confirmed flu cases in nursing homes, because so few residents are tested, added Dr. McGeer. If labs had examined specimens from everyone in the studies, the results would likely have shown a reduction in confirmed flu cases, too, she said.

The new paper's co-author is Dr. Tom Jefferson, a British epidemiologist who heads vaccine research for the respected Cochrane Collaboration -- and who has earned a reputation as a scientific dissident for his outspoken criticism of flu vaccination.

In media interviews last year, Dr. Jefferson was quoted as saying he "can't see any reason" for vaccinating anyone against flu -- arguing the shots did nothing to save lives -- and that most influenza-vaccine studies are "rubbish."

Dr. McGeer said she finds it "mind boggling" that medical journals that publish Dr. Jefferson's work do not question his provocative analyses.

"Scientists are passionate about what they do. All of us have belief systems and sometimes, as with any human endeavour, your belief system overwhelms the scientific evidence," she said. "The purpose of scientific method, the purpose of publication is to get back the objectivity ... And we are not doing that effectively with Dr. Jefferson."

The stakes in the debate are high. Governments spent more than $400-million on acquiring H1N1 pandemic vaccine for Canadians. The Ontario government alone spends about $23-million annually in providing seasonal-flu shots free to anyone who wants them.

Public health and hospital officials have also lobbied hard to increase the percentage of health-care workers who get vaccinated, with a handful of Canadian facilities making the practice mandatory for their staff.

The Public Health Agency of Canada, which oversaw the pandemic flu battle, will study the Cochrane review's findings carefully, said Nadia Mostafa, an agency spokeswoman. The agency recognizes that "it is not effective to only immunize and not take any other infection-prevention measures," she noted.

The review by Dr. Thomas and Dr. Jefferson analyzed five studies on the issue conducted between 1997 and 2009 -- four of them randomized, controlled trials -- using guidelines set out by Cochrane, which does systematic reviews of the effects of drugs and other health measures.

They concluded that vaccinating staff had no proven impact on the amount of laboratory-confirmed flu cases among elderly residents, the number of related pneumonia cases or pneumonia-linked deaths, which the authors said would be the most direct outcomes of flu-shot campaigns.

Dr. Thomas underlined his study's call for high-quality research into other anti-flu measures, such as enhanced use of hand washing, face masks, early detection of the virus with nose swabs and quarantining nursing-homes.

He said he aggressively encouraged such strategies during a previous role as director of long-term care homes in Ottawa, and the facilities' death rates were among the lowest in the city.

Related Links:
* Flu Vaccines Cost A Fortune And Don't Work
Eben Harrell, Time Magazine
* New Research Shows Annual Flu Vaccine Complete Waste Of Money
Jenny Hope, Daily Mail
* Influenza Vaccines: Poor Evidence for Effectiveness in Elderly
Press Release, Science Daily
UK Web Hosting by Fri, March 12th, 2010. 10:36 am